Search "affiliate analytics tool" and you get a jumbled list that mixes four completely different kinds of software. Pick the wrong category and you'll either overpay for media-buyer complexity you don't need or install a traffic tool that can't see a single dollar of your commissions. So before the comparison, the honest framing: there are four types, and they solve different problems.
Full disclosure up front: Clickolytics is our tool. We'll place it accurately — including where competitors clearly beat it — because a comparison you can't trust is worthless.
The four types (this is the real decision)
1. Network-data aggregators — wecantrack, Affilimate, Strackr, Trackonomics. These pull your commission data out of each affiliate network's API and combine it into one dashboard. wecantrack advertises integrations with hundreds of networks and can push affiliate SubID data into GA4; Affilimate works at the link and content level with heatmaps and revenue attribution for editorial teams. Their strength is breadth across networks — if your revenue is scattered across ShareASale, CJ, Impact, Awin and Amazon, they consolidate it. Pricing sits in the roughly $59–$97/month range with free trials. Best for multi-network publishers who log into a dozen dashboards.
2. Media-buyer trackers — Voluum, RedTrack, Binom, Keitaro, BeMob. Built for paid traffic: server-to-server postbacks, funnel split-testing, bid optimization, EPC/CR/ROI across ad sources. Powerful, and overkill for a content site — you'd pay for campaign machinery you'll never use. Only relevant if you're buying traffic.
3. General & privacy web analytics — GA4, Plausible, Fathom, Matomo, Clicky. These measure traffic well. None of them understand affiliate revenue — the sale happens on the merchant's site, so they can show you clicks but never EPC or earnings per page. GA4 is free and ubiquitous; Plausible and Fathom are cookieless and pleasant. All of them leave the monetization question unanswered.
4. First-party, on-site affiliate analytics — Clickolytics. Records clicks and behavior on your own pages with a first-party, cookieless tracker, then joins them to the commission data you import, so you get EPC and revenue per page without a cookie banner. Narrower network coverage than the aggregators; built for an operator watching their own portfolio.
How to choose, by use case
- You promote across many networks and just want the money in one place → a network aggregator (wecantrack or Affilimate). Nothing beats them for pulling revenue out of dozens of network APIs.
- You buy paid traffic → a media-buyer tracker (Voluum, RedTrack). You need S2S postbacks and funnel testing.
- You only care about traffic and hate cookie banners → Plausible or Fathom. Clean, cookieless, and cheap — just don't expect revenue.
- You want first-party, cookieless tracking that ties on-site clicks to revenue and shows EPC per page → Clickolytics. This is the specific gap it's built for.
Most serious publishers end up with two tools: an aggregator for cross-network revenue totals, and a first-party on-site tracker for page-level click and behavior data. They answer different questions.
Where Clickolytics wins — and where it doesn't
Being honest about our own tool, per the framing above.
Where it wins: it's the only option in the matrix that is both cookieless/first-party and ties on-site clicks to revenue with EPC. There's no cookie banner to add, it keeps measuring as third-party cookies degrade, and it's built around the metric that matters — earnings per click per page — rather than treating revenue as an afterthought. For an operator running a portfolio of content sites who wants privacy-first, per-page click-to-revenue data, that combination is genuinely hard to find elsewhere.
Where it loses: it does not match wecantrack's or Affilimate's breadth of automated network integrations. Clickolytics brings revenue in by importing your network earnings (and reads Amazon at the tracking-ID level), rather than pulling live from hundreds of network APIs. If your priority is one-click aggregation across many networks, an aggregator is the better fit, full stop. And like every tool, it inherits the industry-wide limit that Amazon won't hand ordinary Associates true per-page earnings — per-page is an estimate from click share, not an exact figure, for everyone.
The thing that matters more than the tool
Whichever you choose, judge it on one question: can it tell you what each page earns per click? A dashboard full of sessions and bounce rate is vanity; a tool that ranks your pages by EPC is a decision engine. Traffic tools can't answer it, media-buyer trackers answer it for ads not content, aggregators answer it at the network level, and on-site trackers answer it per page. Buy for the answer, not the feature list — and if you're weighing cookieless first-party tracking, our take on why cookieless analytics works lays out the reasoning.
See EPC per page across your whole portfolio: Clickolytics ties first-party, cookieless click tracking to the revenue each page produces. See how it works →
Frequently asked questions
What's the best analytics tool for an affiliate site? It depends on the job: aggregators (wecantrack, Affilimate) for multi-network revenue; media-buyer trackers (Voluum, RedTrack) for paid traffic; privacy analytics (Plausible, Fathom) for traffic only; first-party on-site tracking with EPC per page (Clickolytics).
Aggregators vs on-site trackers? Aggregators pull revenue from many network APIs (breadth); on-site trackers record clicks/behavior on your pages and tie them to imported revenue (first-party, cookieless detail). Many publishers use one of each.
Does GA4 work for affiliate sites? Only for traffic — it tracks outbound clicks as events but has no affiliate revenue, so no EPC or per-page earnings.
Is cookieless worth it? Increasingly yes — no cookie banner, and it keeps measuring as third-party cookies degrade, at the cost of storing less individual-level detail.
Related reading
- What Is EPC? — the metric to judge any tool by.
- Cookieless Analytics for Affiliates — why first-party tracking is becoming table stakes.
- Affiliate Revenue Attribution Explained — tying sales back to pages.
- How to Track Affiliate Links — the tracking foundations underneath any tool.
- Visitor Behavior Metrics That Predict Revenue — which numbers actually matter.